Hundreds of practices were hit with an onerous compulsory questionnaire this week. Jaimie Kaffash considers the Competition and Market Authority's latest action in its landmark review
It came as a bit of a shock for independent practices this week to be confronted with what many thought could be a scam: a demand for all their financial information over the past three years within two weeks or face a potential fine up to £30,000.
This wasn’t a scam – it was sheer bad luck on their part. Because the Competition and Markets Authority had randomly selected 400 independent practices for this exercise.
‘For the avoidance of doubt, we have no concerns about your business individually,’ the letter read. ‘Your practice was chosen at random. We are contacting a range of independent dental practices in each UK nation. However… you must respond to our information request.’
The financial punishment for failing to do so would be severe. The accompanying attachment reassures practices that ‘such amount shall not exceed £30,000’ or ‘1% of the total value of the turnover (both in and outside the UK) of the enterprises owned or controlled by the person’.
The CMA says that these fines are only an option if practices have no reasonable excuse for the failure the comply.
But they do remain a possibility, and there is not much solace from the BDA, either. ‘Practices are legally required to respond and may face financial penalties if they fail to do so,’ its advice confirms.
‘We were informed of this exercise on Wednesday 18 November, but the CMA did not share what information it would be requesting,’ the BDA adds. ‘We understand that the 400 practices have been selected as a random sample, but the CMA has not shared further detail on this.’
Onerous questioning
GDPUK has seen a copy of the spreadsheet those 400 practices are compelled to complete, and the task is onerous. The mailout to independents follows a similar exercise to one it did with corporates in previous months. GDPUK understands that one corporate said it took three people a week to complete the task (although, of course, these bigger businesses would require much more work.)
There is not a huge amount of time to complete the work – the deadline is 5pm UK time on Tuesday 8 December 2026.
The survey is in three parts: ‘initial questions’, which mainly centre around workload; ‘practices and operations’, which are around pricing, basic information and staffing; and ‘financial info’, which asks for account details over the past three years.
For the initial questions, practices are asked to describe the ‘remuneration arrangements for the principal’, as well as:
- Estimating how much time the principal spends on paid and unpaid clinical and administrative activity.;
- Questions around the principal’s career, including the number of years qualified, whether they have specialist status and any other roles;
- Whether the principal left any profit in the business for the purpose of a future planned sale;
- Details around any associates within the practice, including revenue share and what costs they are responsible for.
The second section focuses on the main practice information. Respondents are asked for all details for up to two practices (any more, and they are included in the corporates survey). This includes:
- Names, address, physical size and property type of the practice;
- Ownership and value of the premises;
- The lowest price listed and the amount of NHS remuneration they received for each of the following treatments: new patient consultation; amalgam filling; composite white filling; hygiene appointment; emergency appointment; and routine exam;
- Number of staff, including principals, associates, salaried dentists, and the total clinical hours of those staff.
The third and final part is all about the finances over the past three years, and it is this part that likely involves the most workload. The lucky practices are asked for the following information for the 2023, 2024 and 2025 financial years:
- Financial year-end date and the accounting standard used;
- Total revenue, and broken down into private, NHS and other (eg product sales);
- Staffing costs and fees, and all other costs;
- Interest income and expense;
- Dividends and drawings;
- Gross profit and EBITDA;
- A breakdown of revenue based on which category of staff earned the revenue.
In a separate notice sent to the random chosen practices, the CMA notes: ‘We understand that responding may take time and require you to bring together information that you may not have immediately to hand. We have therefore kept the questions as targeted and focused as possible.’
It adds that it takes the confidentiality of the responses seriously, but stops short of promising not to publish: ‘In the limited circumstances where disclosure and/or publication is required, we must consider whether the disclosure of that information might significantly harm the legitimate business interests of the business to which it relates and, so far as possible, disclose the minimum necessary.’
What the review is all about
It is the latest in their review into private dentistry, which is focusing on five areas: consumer journey and choice; competition; conduct; regulatory frameworks; and market outcomes.
The headline finding of the report, which will publish in March 2027, will undoubtedly focus on the cost of private dentistry for what they call ‘consumers’ (though dentists would probably prefer the term ‘patients’). It was commissioned by former chancellor Rachel Reeves due to what she claimed was a ‘scourge of hidden costs, lack of transparency and overtreatment’ which she claimed had ‘blighted families’ for too long.
The BDA pointed out these figures were based on ‘one market study carried out by an insurance agency’ that was an ‘outlier survey’, with their own figures revealing a real-terms reduction in private dental costs against inflation of 8% between 2021 and 2025.
The answers to this latest survey will feed into their findings. And these findings may carry significant weight. As GDPUK reported in March, if the CMA finds serious concerns with private dentistry, it could decide to launch a formal investigation and impose legally-binding measures. This is what happened with the vets’ market and in March, the watchdog ordered practices to impose price caps on prescription fees and publish their price lists.
An opportunity
For its part, a CMA spokesperson said: ‘Independent dental practices represent around two-thirds of the market so it’s important that we receive information from them alongside larger groups. Statutory information requests are a standard part of our process to gather information to inform our work.
'We understand responding to these requests can be time consuming, so we have made the information request as focused as possible. Anyone with questions about this specific request can get in touch with the CMA.’
These are certainly time consuming, regardless of how focused the questions are. And the BDA warns of an added complication – it says it is ‘concerned that some requests have been sent to practice managers rather than practice owners’. It advises practices to check that correspondence hasn’t been missed through staff absence or annual leave.
Some dentists and practice owners that have spoken to GDPUK say that this provides an opportunity to refute some of those figures put out by government. As one puts it: ‘If the profession wants to actually be listened to they have to provide the data that substantiates their position, and this is one way of doing it.’
Another argues that this is a case of the government not wanting to pay for an NHS service, but wanting others to take the fall for this. But information from independents can help refute this. This is especially the case with corporates already being asked – their economies of scale will mean the picture is distorted unless smaller practices have their say.
As one LDC chair put it, this is ‘at a time when staff illness peaks, and patients are keen to complete treatment before Christmas’. However, they add: ‘Of course it's helpful for the CMA to understand the pressures and risks practices face.’
For those 400 chosen practices, this might seem a poisoned chalice. But it might just be that they have the chance to set the record straight and prevent punitive measures being imposed next year.