You will have received many emails promising to be put on page one of the Google rankings. But what does this actually mean? And what action can you take against them? SEO expert Bogdan Matanie explains
On 13 October, an email reached my inbox from the 'head of marketing' of a link-building firm. 'We place 5,000+ links a month from a database of 50,000+ sites, sorted by country,' it said. 'Would you like see [sic] a few examples for Spain?' Eight days later a different firm, also signed by its 'head of marketing', wrote: 'We’ve built a database of 50,000+ sites sorted by country, niche, and quality signals … Open to seeing a few examples from Spain?'
Same script, new letterhead. The first firm gave its address as 30 N Gould St, Sheridan, Wyoming, a building that, according to The Sheridan Press, 'is home to 26 commercial registered agents representing close to 300,000 of Wyoming’s 830,000 limited liability companies'. That address tells you nothing about who you would be paying.
I run an SEO consultancy, so link sellers find me more often than they find a dental practice. The kind of email practices see most works the same way. One I received read: 'Would you like to work toward better Google positions for your website? I’d be happy to explain our approach.' There was no name on it. When I didn’t reply to the link sellers, both chased me two days later. Cold-email software does the chasing, so silence won’t stop it. The spam filter will.
What does a page-one guarantee buy?
Google’s guidance for site owners is blunt: 'No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.' The same page warns: 'Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue.'
Firms that guarantee page one get round this by choosing the phrases. My own search console shows what such a ranking is worth. Since 2 October, my site has been the first Google result for 'how to get more private dental patients' on most days it appeared. In those six weeks, Google showed it 36 times, less than once a day, and nobody clicked. It would look impressive in a monthly report. It is worth nothing to a practice.
What about 'appear in ChatGPT'?
This year the same pitch arrives with a new label: getting the practice into ChatGPT and other AI search tools. Ask which questions, in which assistant, and how the firm would measure it. If they can’t say, it’s the page-one guarantee again.
Can they email the practice without permission?
It depends on how the practice is set up. Under the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR), a sole trader, or an ordinary partnership in England, Wales or Northern Ireland, is an individual subscriber. The ICO’s business-to-business guidance says these may be sent marketing emails only with specific consent or under the 'soft opt-in', which needs contact details obtained 'in the course of a sale or negotiation of a sale'. A cold pitch doesn’t qualify. A limited company, an LLP or a Scottish partnership can be emailed without consent.
Whatever the practice’s legal form, the sender must not disguise or conceal its identity and must give a valid address for opt-out requests (PECR regulation 23). Since 5 February 2026 the ICO can fine up to £17.5 million or 4% of global turnover for PECR breaches.
Report unwanted marketing emails with the ICO’s spam email reporting tool, and forward suspected scams to the NCSC at [email protected]. The ICO says it doesn’t respond to complaints individually, and senders abroad are hard to reach, so for most of these emails the spam filter is the fix.
Five checks before anyone replies
They are short enough to pin up at reception.
- Does the email mention something only a person who looked would know, such as a treatment page or a broken booking link? 'Your website looks professional' fits every website.
- A real company. A full name, a website on the company’s own domain and, for a UK firm, a company number you can check free on Companies House.
- The searches. Which exact phrases, and how many people search for each one every month?
- The guarantee. How can they guarantee what Google says nobody can?
- The Google Business Profile, Google Ads account, domain and website should be in the practice’s name from day one.
One more for reception: Google says it 'will never try to convince you to pay to maintain your business profile' and will 'never ask you for payment information over the phone'. Report a caller who claims otherwise on Google’s third-party complaint form.
Already signed up?
Take back the accounts first, then give notice. There is no legal 14-day cooling-off period: the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 protect consumers, and a dentist signing for the practice is acting for the business.
- Google business profile. If the agency holds it and won’t hand it over, request ownership through Google; the current owner has three days to respond.
- Google Ads. The practice should be an admin on the account, with billing in its name.
- Domain, website and search console. All should be in the practice’s name, and the practice should hold every login.
- In writing, exactly as the contract’s termination clause requires. Keep a copy.
The cheapest protection is still the first one: don’t reply. A reply tells the sender that a real person reads the inbox, which is all the software was fishing for.
Bogdan Matanie is the founder of Cogrank, a Google Ads and SEO consultancy for UK private dental practices.